As a top-rated headshot photographer based in New York City, I've had the pleasure of working with thousands of actors - from first-timers to seasoned professionals. Whether you're submitting for television, film, theater, or commercials, your headshot is your first impression. It's your calling card - and it has to work for you.
Unfortunately, many actors make simple but costly mistakes when it comes to their headshots. These errors can mean the difference between getting called in for an audition or being passed over completely. The good news? They're all easily avoidable.
Here are the top 5 actor headshot mistakes I see regularly - and how I help you fix them in every session.
We've all seen it - headshots where the actor's skin is so smoothed over, they look more like a cartoon character than a real person. While it's tempting to want to "perfect" your look, casting directors want to see the real you.
Over-retouching can be a red flag. It gives the impression that you're hiding something - and that you may not look like your photo when you walk into the room. That can damage your credibility and cost you roles.
How I fix it: At Dorothy Shi Photography, I believe in light, professional retouching that enhances your best features - while keeping the authenticity that casting directors trust.
A headshot isn't just a photo - it's a glimpse into your personality. Too many actors make the mistake of showing up with blank stares, forced smiles, or no clear energy behind the eyes.
Casting professionals are looking for connection, presence, and emotional clarity. If your photo doesn't convey anything, it won't spark their interest.
How I fix it: I coach every client through a variety of expressions that align with their casting type. Whether you're the girl-next-door, the edgy villain, or the quirky best friend - I help bring those subtle traits out in your shots.
Busy prints, neon colors, or outfits that don't flatter your frame can take attention away from your face - which should always be the focus of a great headshot.
Remember: the goal isn't to showcase your fashion sense - it's to create a clean, camera-friendly look that allows casting to imagine you in different roles.
How I fix it: I provide wardrobe guidance for every shoot, helping you select outfits that are simple, well-fitted, and photograph beautifully. I even recommend colors based on your skin tone and background choices.
A great headshot is clean, crisp, and professional. Yet many actors still use DIY photos or outdated shots taken in poor lighting with cluttered or uninspired backgrounds.
These low-quality images simply don't compete - especially in a city as competitive as New York.
How I fix it: My sessions are done with professional studio lighting, seamless backgrounds, and cinematic outdoor locations (if desired) to give your headshots a polished, industry-standard finish.
Your headshot should represent what you look like today - not five years ago. If you've changed your hairstyle, aged noticeably, gained or lost weight, or made any major appearance shifts, it's time to update.
Casting directors expect your headshot to be an accurate reflection of who they'll meet in the audition room. Showing up looking different can create confusion - and again, break trust.
How I fix it: I recommend refreshing your headshots every 1-2 years, or anytime your look changes significantly. My repeat clients often update seasonally to reflect their current casting vibe.
I specialize in helping actors put their best face forward - literally. Whether you're just starting out or building your next round of submissions, I'd love to work with you to create dynamic, effective headshots that get you noticed.
Visit me at: www.dorothyshiphotography.com
Let's make your next headshot your best one yet.
#ActorHeadshotNewYork #NYCPhotographer #HeadshotTips #DorothyShiPhotography